The Perfect Arnold Palmer: Your New Favorite Refreshing Drink

There’s something magical about the combination of iced tea and lemonade that has kept the Arnold Palmer drink beloved for decades. Named after the legendary golfer who famously ordered this mix at country clubs across America, this refreshing beverage has become a summertime staple that transcends the golf course. Whether you’re hosting a backyard barbecue, relaxing on the porch after a long day, or looking for a non-alcoholic option that pleases everyone, the Arnold Palmer delivers every single time.

What makes this drink so incredibly special is the perfect balance between the smooth, slightly bitter notes of black tea and the bright, tangy sweetness of fresh lemonade. When you take that first sip, you’re greeted with a rush of cool citrus that immediately gives way to the mellow depth of the tea, creating a flavor profile that’s simultaneously energizing and soothing. The golden-amber color is absolutely beautiful in a tall glass filled with ice, and the aroma combines the subtle earthiness of brewed tea with the zingy brightness of lemon that practically screams refreshment.

This drink works beautifully for any occasion throughout the year, though it truly shines during warm weather months. It’s sophisticated enough for dinner parties yet casual enough for everyday enjoyment. The best part? You can customize the ratio of tea to lemonade to suit your personal taste, making it stronger and more tea-forward or sweeter and more citrus-heavy depending on your mood.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Incredibly refreshing – The combination of tea and lemonade creates the ultimate thirst-quencher that’s more interesting than either drink alone
• Budget-friendly – Made with simple, inexpensive ingredients that you probably already have in your pantry
• Naturally energizing – The caffeine from black tea provides a gentle pick-me-up without the jitters of coffee or energy drinks
• Customizable sweetness – You control exactly how sweet you want it, making it perfect for everyone from sugar-lovers to those watching their intake
• Kid and adult approved – This non-alcoholic beverage is universally loved and appropriate for all ages
• Make-ahead friendly – Brew your tea and prepare your lemonade in advance, then mix individual servings as needed throughout the week

Ingredients Explained

Understanding what each component brings to your Arnold Palmer will help you create the best possible version every time. The black tea forms the backbone of this drink, providing depth, subtle tannins, and a gentle caffeine boost that makes it more than just flavored sugar water. Traditional black teas like English Breakfast, Ceylon, or even plain Lipton work beautifully because they have enough body to stand up to the lemonade without getting completely overwhelmed. The natural astringency of black tea is what keeps this drink from tasting one-dimensional or cloyingly sweet.

Fresh lemon juice is what elevates a homemade Arnold Palmer from good to absolutely phenomenal. While bottled lemon juice technically works, nothing compares to the bright, vibrant flavor of juice squeezed from real lemons. Fresh lemon juice has essential oils and a complexity that bottled versions simply can’t replicate, and it makes your drink taste alive rather than artificial.

Sweetener is essential for balancing the tartness of lemon and the bitterness of tea. Whether you use regular sugar, honey, agave nectar, or a sugar substitute, the sweetener rounds out all the flavors and makes everything harmonious. The amount you use is entirely personal preference, which is why homemade versions are so much better than store-bought.

Cold water and ice might seem obvious, but they’re crucial for diluting the concentrated flavors to drinkable perfection and providing that ice-cold refreshment that makes this drink so satisfying.

Step-by-Step Tips

Brew your tea strong and let it cool completely before mixing your Arnold Palmer. Since you’ll be adding ice and lemonade, a stronger tea concentrate ensures you still taste the tea in the final drink. Brew it at about 1.5 times your normal strength, and always let it cool to room temperature or chill it in the refrigerator rather than adding ice directly to hot tea, which waters it down too quickly.

Sweeten while the tea is still warm if you’re using granulated sugar. Sugar dissolves almost instantly in warm liquid but takes forever to dissolve in cold tea, leaving you with gritty sediment at the bottom of your glass. Stir your sweetener into the freshly brewed tea, then let everything cool together.

Taste and adjust as you go because the beauty of making your own Arnold Palmer is customization. Start with a 50/50 ratio of tea to lemonade, then adjust based on your preference. Some people love a 60/40 tea-to-lemonade ratio for a more tea-forward flavor, while others prefer 40/60 for a sweeter, more citrusy drink.

Use filtered water if your tap water has a strong taste or smell. Since this drink is so simple, the quality of your water really matters and can make the difference between a good Arnold Palmer and a great one.

Strain your lemon juice to remove seeds and pulp for a cleaner, more refined drink. While some people enjoy pulpy lemonade, most prefer their Arnold Palmer smooth and clear.

Substitutions & Variations

Tea variations open up a world of possibilities. Try green tea for a lighter, more delicate version with less caffeine. White tea creates an extremely subtle Arnold Palmer that’s perfect for those who find black tea too strong. For a caffeine-free option, use decaf black tea or herbal teas like rooibos, which provides a naturally sweet, slightly nutty flavor that pairs beautifully with lemon. Peach tea creates what’s sometimes called a “John Daly” (another famous golfer), adding fruity sweetness to the classic combination.

Sweetener alternatives let you customize for dietary needs or flavor preferences. Honey creates a more complex, floral sweetness and blends especially well with tea. Agave nectar dissolves easily even in cold liquids and has a neutral sweetness. Maple syrup adds an interesting depth, though use it sparingly as the flavor can be assertive. For sugar-free versions, stevia, monk fruit sweetener, or erythritol work well, though you may need to experiment with amounts since they’re sweeter than sugar.

Lime instead of lemon creates a slightly different flavor profile that’s a bit more tropical and less classically tart. Some people prefer the mellower acidity of lime, and it pairs especially well if you’re using green tea.

Add fresh mint, basil, or lavender for an herbal twist that makes your Arnold Palmer feel fancy and spa-like. Muddle a few leaves in the bottom of your glass before adding the drink, or brew the herbs directly with your tea.

Make it sparkling by using sparkling water or club soda in place of some or all of the still water for a fizzy version that feels extra special and festive.

Storage & Reheating

Brewed tea can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 5 days in an airtight container or pitcher. This makes it incredibly convenient to have tea ready to mix with lemonade whenever you want an Arnold Palmer. Just make sure it’s completely cooled before refrigerating to prevent condensation and bacterial growth.

Homemade lemonade keeps for about 5 to 7 days when refrigerated in a sealed container. The flavor actually improves slightly after a day as the sugar fully dissolves and the flavors meld together. If your lemonade starts to taste slightly fermented or develops an off smell, discard it.

Pre-mixed Arnold Palmer is best consumed within 3 days for optimal flavor. After that, the tea can start to taste stale and the lemon flavor may become muted. Store it in a glass pitcher or bottle rather than plastic if possible, as plastic can sometimes absorb flavors.

Freezing isn’t recommended for pre-mixed Arnold Palmer as the tea can become cloudy and bitter when thawed, and the texture becomes watery. However, you can freeze leftover tea or lemonade separately in ice cube trays, then use these cubes in fresh Arnold Palmers so they don’t get diluted as they melt.

For best results, mix individual servings as needed rather than making a huge batch all at once. Keep your brewed tea and lemonade separate in the fridge, then combine them fresh in each glass. This ensures every Arnold Palmer tastes as vibrant and delicious as the first one.

Serving Ideas

Arnold Palmers are incredibly versatile and pair beautifully with just about any casual meal. They’re particularly perfect alongside grilled foods like burgers, hot dogs, barbecue chicken, or grilled vegetables. The refreshing citrus and tea combination cuts through rich, smoky flavors and cleanses your palate between bites.

Serve them with picnic classics like fried chicken, potato salad, coleslaw, and sandwiches for the ultimate summer spread. The drink’s lightness complements heavier, mayonnaise-based sides without weighing you down.

For brunch, Arnold Palmers are a sophisticated non-alcoholic option that pairs wonderfully with quiches, breakfast sandwiches, pancakes, or avocado toast. They’re refreshing enough to wake up your taste buds but not so heavy that they compete with your meal.

Appetizers and snacks like chips and guacamole, vegetable platters with hummus, bruschetta, or cheese boards all work beautifully with this drink. The tea provides just enough substance to make it feel special while the lemon keeps things light.

Consider setting up an Arnold Palmer bar at parties where guests can customize their own ratios of tea to lemonade, add fresh herbs, or even spike their drinks with vodka or bourbon if desired. Provide different types of tea and fun garnishes like lemon wheels, fresh mint, and colorful straws for a memorable interactive experience.

FAQs

Can I use store-bought lemonade?
Absolutely! While fresh lemonade tastes best, using quality store-bought lemonade is a perfectly acceptable shortcut that still produces a delicious Arnold Palmer. Look for brands made with real lemon juice rather than just lemon flavoring, and choose one that isn’t too sweet. You may want to dilute store-bought lemonade slightly with water since it’s often more concentrated than homemade versions. Simply Lemonade and similar premium brands work wonderfully.

What’s the best ratio of tea to lemonade?
The traditional Arnold Palmer uses a 50/50 ratio of iced tea to lemonade, but this is absolutely flexible based on personal preference. If you love tea, try a 60/40 or even 70/30 tea-to-lemonade ratio. If you prefer it sweeter and more citrus-forward, go with 40/60 or 30/70 in favor of lemonade. Start with equal parts and adjust from there—you really can’t mess this up!

Does it have to be black tea?
Not at all! Black tea is the traditional choice and what Arnold Palmer himself preferred, but you can use whatever tea you enjoy. Green tea creates a lighter, more delicate version. Herbal teas like hibiscus or berry blends add fruity notes. Decaf black tea works great if you’re avoiding caffeine. The key is brewing whatever tea you choose strong enough that it doesn’t get lost when mixed with lemonade.

Can I make this sugar-free?
Yes, sugar-free Arnold Palmers are easy to make and still delicious. Use unsweetened tea and make your lemonade with a sugar substitute like stevia, erythritol, or monk fruit sweetener. You can also use sugar-free store-bought lemonade if you prefer. Keep in mind that some sugar substitutes have a slightly different taste than regular sugar, so you may need to experiment to find the amount and type you prefer.

How do I keep it from getting watered down?
The best trick is to make ice cubes from tea or lemonade instead of plain water. As these cubes melt, they add more flavor rather than diluting your drink. You can also brew your tea extra strong to account for ice dilution, or serve your Arnold Palmer over fewer ice cubes and keep it refrigerated between servings. Another option is to keep your tea and lemonade very cold so you need less ice in the first place.

Can I make it ahead for a party?
You can definitely prepare the components ahead, but it’s best to mix the final drinks closer to serving time. Brew your tea and make your lemonade the day before, keeping them refrigerated separately. About an hour before guests arrive, mix them together in a large pitcher or beverage dispenser. If you mix it too far in advance, the tea can start to taste flat and the lemon flavor may fade. Having the components ready makes it easy to refresh your batch if needed.

Print